Smarter Spend: How Legal Teams Can Efficiently Manage Outside Counsel

Outside counsel remains one of the largest and least predictable expenses for legal departments. Traditional hourly billing models and uneven matter allocation can create outsized costs and misaligned incentives.

This blog focuses on the practical steps legal leaders can take to maintain quality legal work while controlling spend and improving predictability. By adopting a structured, metrics-driven outside counsel program, leaders can realize measurable savings and stronger alignment with business goals. We’ll walk through the core challenge, the strategic approach successful teams use, and a concise implementation checklist you can adapt to your organization.

The Challenge

Outside counsel expenses often represent the most significant portion of a legal department’s budget, and the way those dollars are spent is under more scrutiny than ever. Traditional hourly billing models can create misaligned incentives between law firms and corporate legal teams, especially when it comes to efficiency, transparency, and cost predictability.

At the same time, many matters handled by outside counsel involve work that could be performed more efficiently through alternative staffing models or modern legal technology. And with rising complexity, fee pressures, and heightened expectations from the business, legal departments are finding that predictability and cost control are increasingly challenging — even as overall budgets tighten.

The bottom line: legal leaders must decide which matters genuinely require premium external expertise, and which can be brought in-house or handled under alternative fee arrangements without compromising outcomes.

The Strategic Approach

Leading legal departments are moving beyond rate-by-rate negotiation and implementing comprehensive outside counsel management programs that:

• Prioritize Matter-Level Budgeting: Conduct regular variance analysis to ensure financial predictability and accountability.

• Use Strategic Matter Allocation: Assign work based on complexity, risk, and value to the organization.

• Reclaim eDiscovery and Document Review Spend: Leverage in-house platforms to cull and process data before involving outside counsel, reducing downstream review fees and overall external spend.

• Promote Value-Based Fee Arrangements: Tie compensation to defined outcomes rather than time spent.

• Apply Data-Driven Performance Assessments: Align evaluations with legal department goals and broader business or agency priorities.

This approach supports both corporate goals and public sector mandates for transparency, accountability, and cost-effective service delivery.

An Implementation Checklist: Metrics, KPIs, and Action Steps

Define Success Metrics

• Outside Counsel Spend: Target an 8-12% annual reduction in external legal expenses.

• Budget Predictability: Reduce variance between forecasted and actual legal spend.

• AFA Utilization: Increase the percentage of matters managed under alternative fee models.

• Satisfaction: Track internal stakeholder satisfaction with outside counsel performance.

• Alignment: Ensure legal spend is aligned with broader cost-containment goals.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

• Blended Rates: Monitor average blended hourly rates by matter type.

• Budget Variance: Track deviations by firm, practice area, and matter.

• AFA Effectiveness: Evaluate outcomes and savings compared to traditional billing.

• Leverage Ratios: Assess timekeeper mix for cost efficiency.

• Cost Avoidance: Quantify savings achieved through proactive legal spend management.

Action Steps

1. Build a Tiered Panel: Establish a structured law firm panel with clear guidelines for matter allocation.

2. Standardize Budgeting Tools: Introduce consistent budget templates and tracking mechanisms for external matters.

3. Launch an AFA Program: Develop and implement a formal alternative fee arrangement strategy with outcome-focused success metrics.

4. Conduct Performance Reviews: Hold quarterly business reviews with key firms to assess performance and value delivery.

Why Smarter Outside Counsel Management Matters

Efficient management is about aligning legal spend with outcomes, improving predictability, and freeing budget for high-value legal work — not penny-pinching. By combining matter-level budgeting, alternative fee arrangements, technology-enabled insourcing, and data-driven performance reviews, legal leaders can preserve quality while reducing cost and risk.

Treat your outside counsel program as an operational asset rather than a passive expense line.

Want to go deeper? This blog builds on themes from our broader 2026 strategic playbook, which outlines five priorities for legal leaders and provides a practical roadmap to support strategy, KPIs, and long-term value creation.

Get the tools you need to strategically address evolving challenges and drive operational excellence.